Crooked Lake Mercantile » Deli / Bakery

We are located at the four corners of Branchport, on the northwest branch of Keuka Lake, in the beautiful Finger Lakes region of Upstate New York. Since 1993 we have been serving the public in our 1890’s country store.

All things Keuka, gifts, souvenirs, men’s, women’s and children’s apparel, toys and so much more are interspersed throughout our store.

Our Antiques and Oddities Co-op melds the unique merchandise offered by eight individual dealers in one 2000 sq. ft. space.

Deli Items

Deli Meats

Honey Ham, Roast Beef (In House), Hard Salami, Pepperoni (Sliced or Chunk), Roast Turkey, Smoked Turkey*

Deli Cheeses

American, Provolone, Swiss, Hot Pepper American

Store Baked Breads

White, Wheat, Rye


Plain, Everything, Asigo, French Toast

Wheat, Spinach, Jalapeno Cheddar, Italian Herb


Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickles, Banana Peppers, Horseradish, Salt & Pepper, Italian Dressing, Hellmann's Mayonnaise, Spicy Brown Mustard, Yellow Mustard, Honey Mustard


Keuka Slaw, Black Bean and Citrus, Greek Pasta, Fruit, Jalapeno Potato, German Red Potato, Traditional White Potato, Tabouli, Traditional 3 Bean, Italian Pasta, Tuna & Shells, Quinoa, Hummus, Deviled Eggs Made to order or depending on cook's mood!

Fresh In Store Baked Goods

White, Wheat, Rye, Honey Oatmeal*, Cinnamon Swirl*, Raisin*, Italian

Specialty Breads

Pumpkin, Lemon Poppyseed, Banana, Orange / Almond / Blueberry

Cinnamon Rolls

(with or without frosting)


Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, Ginger, Oatmeal Raisin, Macadamia Nut

An Ever-changing Variety of Muffins
Choose triple berry or one of our many creations baked to perfection by combining our scrumptious banana or pumpkin bread doughs with a multitude of ingredients including nuts, dried fruits, candies & chocolate.


Plain, Everything, Asiago, French Toast


Grape (available gluten free)

* Denotes Seasonal

Your One-Stop Shop on Keuka Lake

Crooked Lake Mercantile Grocery


A full line of groceries and home staples, to accommodate your every need, can be found on the wooden shelves of yesteryear. If we don’t have it, we can get it.

More About Our Grocery

Crooked Lake Mercantile Deli / Bakery


Our deli and bakery features homemade goodies for you to enjoy either here, amidst our warm and welcoming atmosphere, or packed for your picnic elsewhere.

Deli/Bakery Information

Crooked Lake Mercantile Keuka Lake Gifts & Souvenirs

Keuka Lake Gifts & Souvenirs

Shop All Things Keuka! - gifts, souvenirs, men’s, women’s, and children’s apparel, toys and so much more are interspersed throughout our store.

Shop All Things Keuka!